Skip to content

Here’s How We Selected Our 2017 Washington Wine Awards Winners

Meet our tasting panel and the methodology behind our 12th annual wine awards.

By Seattle Magazine Staff July 25, 2017

wine-method

This article originally appeared in the August 2017 issue of Seattle magazine.

Nominations for this year’s Washington Wine Awards were solicited via survey from a panel of Washington wine and food professionals. The top vote-getters in the wineries, winemaker, vineyard and sommelier categories were selected as winners (check out a list of the finalists that impressed our judges here). 

The more than 100 wines receiving the most votes in the varietal categories qualified as finalists for a blind tasting that took place on March 7, 2017. That tasting was conducted by a panel of 17 industry professionals, and finalists were scored using a 20-point system and awarded points for their appeal in sight, smell and taste. The wine with the most points won. Winners in each varietal category were eligible to win Wine of the Year. Wine of the Year winners in red and white wines were selected via a show of hands after a second tasting of the winners for each varietal.

Information in the tasting notes was taken from the tasters’ descriptions of the wines. Tasting panelists who are winemakers were excluded from voting in and writing about categories in which their wines were entered.

Winners of Best Restaurant to Experience Washington Wine and Retail Wine Steward of the Year were selected from nominees put forth by our nominating panel and from our readers’ poll. The final winners were determined by our steering committee. 

Photograph by Hayley Young. Seattle magazine’s Washington Wine Awards 2017 tasting panel from the March 6, 2017 tasting at Metropolist (from left): Jeff Lindsay-Thorsen of RN74; Seattle magazine wine writer Paul Zitarelli of Full Pull Wines; Jeff Cox of PCC Natural Markets; Thomas Price, Master Sommelier; Mark Takagi of Metropolitan Market; Rebecca Murphy of Dallas Morning News; Erica Orr of Orr Wines; Chris Horn of Purple Café; Katelyn Peil of Heavy Restaurant Group; Reggie Daigneault of American NW Distributors; Jeffrey Dorgan of SkyCity at the Needle; Michael Savage or Savage Grace Winery; Paul Swanson of RN74; Rand Sealey of the Review of Washington Wines; Cole Sisson of Doe Bay Wine Company; Chris Lara of John Howie Steak; and Chris Peterson of Avennia Winery.

The Walter Clore Washington Honorarium was chosen by an internal Washington State Wine commission committee. 

For wines to be eligible as a Washington wine for this competition, the winery must be licensed and located in Washington state or located within the boundaries of a federally recognized AVA that includes acreage in Washington. Also, a minimum of 95 percent of the grapes used in the production of the wine must be from a vineyard located within Washington state, or from one of the three federally recognized AVAs that include acreage in Washington state (Columbia Valley, Walla Walla Valley and the Columbia Gorge AVAs).

Best Vineyard Winner must be located in Washington. People, places and wine experiences winners must also be located in Washington. 

For a varietal to be considered in its category, it must be made with at least 75 percent of that grape variety, which must be grown in Washington state.

Seattle magazine’s Washington Wine Awards program is produced by Yashar Shayan.

 

Follow Us

Restaurant Roundup: Holiday Cheer at SLU BRU, StarChefs, and Kabul Closing

Restaurant Roundup: Holiday Cheer at SLU BRU, StarChefs, and Kabul Closing

Here’s what was served up recently in the Emerald City.

Fusion food has an innate ability to bring us together. In the blending of two (or sometimes more) cultures, new perspectives are unlocked and we are all better for it. Esquire is in agreement, as the magazine has selected Lupe’s Situ Tacos, a Mexican-Lebanese taqueria in Ballard, as one of the 33 best new restaurants…

Counter Culture: Sansonina Ristorante Italiano

Counter Culture: Sansonina Ristorante Italiano

An Italian escape hiding in Renton.

Tucked just off Rainier Avenue, across from a Safeway, Sansonina Ristorante Italiano—which opened early in 2019—is the kind of place you drive past for years without noticing until you walk through the door. Once inside, the outside world dissolves, the hum of traffic fades, and suddenly you’re not in Renton anymore. You’re in a dimly…

5 Things to Eat in December

5 Things to Eat in December

This month’s assignment: Take the pressure off. 

There’s something about the end of the year that adds pressure to everything we do. Despite all the talk of holiday cheer and “merry and bright,” heightened expectations can bring a sense of weariness. We’re fretting over feasts and gatherings while working fervently to tie up loose ends—gifts, work, everything—with a pretty bow. Each month,…

Ahead of the Cut

Ahead of the Cut

How a tech-minded home cook turned years of tinkering into a chef’s knife powered by 40,000 vibrations per second.

Scott Heimendinger traces his love for knives back to college, when his dad taught him how to cook over the phone. By his junior year he had saved for his first real knife, a JA Henckels Santoku. Compared with the $9 IKEA knife he had been using, “it felt like a laser… things that used…