The Tastiest Cookies in Seattle
Chocolate chip may be king, but in Seattle, there are so many more cookie types to love
By Chelsea Lin May 22, 2018
This article originally appeared in the June 2018 issue of Seattle magazine.
This article appears in print in the June 2018 issue. Click here to subscribe.
Volumes could be filled about our love for chocolate chip cookies (particularly when sea salt is involved). Yet there are many other, offbeat cookies being turned out by our local, talented bakers that we can’t get enough of. And while you may think anyone (including you) can bake a cookie, these special treats are best left to the pros. Your job? Give them a try.
Hello Robin
Robin Wehl Martin has a whole shop dedicated to cookies, so it makes sense that hers are some of the best in town. Her friend, ice cream maven Molly Moon Neitzel, convinced Martin to open the adorable space—mostly bright and white, with accents of robin’s egg blue, of course. Her cookies (chewy and small compared to those from some other bakeries) are best when they’re served hugging a scoop of Molly Moon’s ice cream.
Our pick: We love a good pun almost as much as we love a good cookie, and the Mackles’more ($2)—an ode to Seattle’s homegrown hip-hopper—is as good as it gets, in the form of a graham cracker topped with a marshmallow-studded chocolate chip cookie and a Theo chocolate chunk.
Capitol Hill, 522 19th Ave. E; 206.735.7970
Hood Famous Bakeshop
People may assume that because they’re beautiful—an unparalleled shade of purple—Chera Amlag’s ube desserts are popular based on looks alone. But anyone who has tried the Filipino-style treats from her petite, utilitarian production kitchen in Ballard, with its small counter of ready-to-go sweets, can verify that her goods are as delicious as they are pretty.
Our pick: There’s only one cookie on the menu, but it’s all you need: The ube cookie ($2) is chewy and buttery, with a distinctive flavor a little like vanilla birthday cake. This cookie is similar to a really great sugar cookie—only purple.
Ballard, 2325 1/2 NW Market St.; 206.486.6429
The London Plane
Bright and ethereal, this Pioneer Square café just feels good; it doesn’t hurt that it makes some of the best pastries in town (as well as composed plates of seasonal salads and fork-worthy toasts).
The menu changes regularly, so try not to be disappointed—as I continue to be—when you discover your favorite peanut-butter-and-jelly thumbprint isn’t available every day. Bonus: The London Plane also supplies the pastries for La Marzocco’s flagship café at KEXP at Seattle Center, so try a bite there as well.
Our pick: Whatever delicate shortbread is available when you visit—be it cacao nib pecan, espresso, Earl Grey, honey ginger or some such ($1.50)—is the ideal teatime treat.
Pioneer Square, 300 Occidental Ave. S; 206.624.1374
Slab Sandwiches and Pie
We promised not to talk about chocolate chip cookies, but if we did, we’d be singing the praises of the salted chocolate chip cookie ($2) from this primarily takeout shop run by Lark chef John Sundstrom, whose fine dining destination is just next door. While this spot specializes more in the savory than the sweet, it does both well.
Our pick: Opt for the made-to-order peanut butter sandwich cookies ($3.50 for two), which have peanut butter cream oozing out from the center and are rolled in light, crispy chicharróns (pork rinds) for the ultimate in salty sweetness.
Capitol Hill, 1201 10th Ave.; 206.790.0967
Lowrider Baking Company
Named for owner Emily Allport’s two dachsunds, this pop-up-and-wholesale-only cookie business gets creative with flavors, such as the unexpectedly delicious lemon ginger; it also mixes in lots of chunks and other ingredients. Allport bakes out of Full Tilt Ice Cream’s White Center location, and most of the time you can find her cookies at all Full Tilt shops (to make into massive ice cream sandwiches).
Our pick: It’s impossible to turn down the Birthday Cake ($2): a soft almond-extract-flavored cookie reminiscent of yellow boxed cake, loaded with white chocolate chips and covered in sprinkles (the little round ones called nonpareils, which offer the best crunch).
Pop-up and wholesale
Mad for Macarons
Cookies’ fancy Parisian cousins, macarons (not macaroons) have stormed Seattle. And they’re not going anywhere anytime soon. Perfect for a cocktail party or a preschool playdate, these macarons are our personal favorites:
Cap’n Crunch ($1.95) from Belle Epicurean
Madison Park, 3109 E Madison St.; 206.466.1320;
Downtown, 925 Fourth Ave.; 206.262.9404
Circus Animal ($2.50) from Trophy Cupcakes
Multiple locations
Raspberry Chardonnay ($2) from Lady Yum
Kirkland, 111 Lake St.; 866.523.9986
Guava-cajeta ($3) from Amandine Bakeshop
Capitol Hill, 1424 11th Ave.; 206.948.2097
Black sesame ($2.50) from Crumble & Flake
Capitol Hill, 1500 E Olive Way; 206.329.1804
Follow Us
Restaurant Roundup: Holiday Cheer at SLU BRU, StarChefs, and Kabul Closing
Here’s what was served up recently in the Emerald City.
Fusion food has an innate ability to bring us together. In the blending of two (or sometimes more) cultures, new perspectives are unlocked and we are all better for it. Esquire is in agreement, as the magazine has selected Lupe’s Situ Tacos, a Mexican-Lebanese taqueria in Ballard, as one of the 33 best new restaurants…
Counter Culture: Sansonina Ristorante Italiano
An Italian escape hiding in Renton.
Tucked just off Rainier Avenue, across from a Safeway, Sansonina Ristorante Italiano—which opened early in 2019—is the kind of place you drive past for years without noticing until you walk through the door. Once inside, the outside world dissolves, the hum of traffic fades, and suddenly you’re not in Renton anymore. You’re in a dimly…
5 Things to Eat in December
This month’s assignment: Take the pressure off.
There’s something about the end of the year that adds pressure to everything we do. Despite all the talk of holiday cheer and “merry and bright,” heightened expectations can bring a sense of weariness. We’re fretting over feasts and gatherings while working fervently to tie up loose ends—gifts, work, everything—with a pretty bow. Each month,…
Ahead of the Cut
How a tech-minded home cook turned years of tinkering into a chef’s knife powered by 40,000 vibrations per second.
Scott Heimendinger traces his love for knives back to college, when his dad taught him how to cook over the phone. By his junior year he had saved for his first real knife, a JA Henckels Santoku. Compared with the $9 IKEA knife he had been using, “it felt like a laser… things that used…