Skip to content

Seattle Culture

Fifth Avenue’s Waitress Delivers

The musical is uplifting, even whimsical at times

By Rob Smith March 19, 2025

Three women in blue uniforms stand behind a kitchen counter with baking supplies, focused like dedicated waitresses on preparing a dish. Shelves with ingredients and utensils line the background, reminiscent of a bustling Fifth Avenue café kitchen.
Porscha Shaw, Kerstin Anderson, and Tori Gresham in Waitress at The 5th Avenue Theatre.
Photo by Tracy Martin. Courtesy of The 5th Avenue Theatre

I loved the movie Waitress when it came out almost two decades ago. I also loved The Fifth Avenue Theatre’s rendition of the musical of the same name.

An almost sold-out crowd last week was boisterous and raucous, with many booing the abusive husband (“Earl,” played by Dane Stokinger) and cheering the relationships between the lead character, Jenna (Kerstin Anderson) and her fellow waitresses (Tori Gresham as “Dawn” and Porscha Shaw as “Becky”). Another big crowd hit was Kennedy Kanagawa as Ogie, Dawn’s awkward but sincere love interest.

The musical and movie versions of Waitress share a similar premise but differ in execution. The film, released in 2007, focuses more on the personal struggles of a small-town waitress and her emotional journey through an abusive marriage and unexpected pregnancy. A key part of the plot involves her relationship with “Joe,” the Old Man who owns the diner (played by Andy Griffith in the movie and Allen Fitzpatrick in the musical). That relationship isn’t as developed in the play, though the storyline is consistent.

The musical, which premiered on Broadway in 2016, incorporates a more whimsical tone with catchy songs that express Jenna’s inner emotions and hopes. The musical’s vibrant numbers and more hopeful empowerment emphasize the importance of self-discovery.

Waitress plays at The Fifth Avenue Theatre through March 30.

Follow Us

Book Excerpt: Old White Man Writing

Book Excerpt: Old White Man Writing

Seattle resident Joshua Gidding examines his own white privilege

In his book, Old White Man Writing, Seattle resident Joshua Gidding attempts to come to terms with his privilege. Gidding grapples with the rapidly changing cultural norms in 21st-century America while examining his own racial biases and prejudices. As Manhattan Book Review notes: “Old White Man Writing is an introspective deep dive into an eventful life…

Glacial Expressions

Glacial Expressions

Local scientist and painter Jill Pelto spotlights climate change in a multi-artist show at Slip Gallery

The divide between the arts and sciences is long-fostered and well-documented. From elementary school onward, children are often singled out for their penchant for math or artistic ability and guided toward classes — and later careers — that align with their right or left brain tendencies. For Jill Pelto — a local climate scientist, painter,…

How Taproot Theatre Survived A Financial Crisis

How Taproot Theatre Survived A Financial Crisis

Theatre is planning for its 50th birthday next year

Karen Lund vividly remembers that sinking feeling she had in the fall of 2023. That was when Lund, producing artistic director of Taproot Theatre Co., first realized that the financially strapped, midsized professional theatre in the Greenwood neighborhood might not survive. The theatre had already weathered the worst of the pandemic, but costs were mounting….

Humanities Washington Fights ‘Midnight’ Cuts

Humanities Washington Fights ‘Midnight’ Cuts

Nonprofit loses previously approved federal grants with little warning

The letter came without warning, like a slap in the face from an invisible hand. Humanities Washington CEO and Executive Director Julie Ziegler had already been talking with peers in other states, and she readied herself for the blow. The National Endowment for the Humanities (think DOGE) had terminated her nonprofit’s previously awarded federal grant…