Skip to content

What’s Good About the New Stand-alone Emergency Rooms

Hospitals say these new freestanding ER's meet a critical care need. Critics say it's more about mak

By Karen West June 13, 2011

topdocs_emergency11_0

Emergency medical care in Washington is getting a radical makeover: Freestanding, “no wait” emergency centers are cropping up in fast-growing suburbs, providing closer-to-home options to those often dreaded, crowded ER waiting rooms in urban hospitals.

These ERs, often in or near trendy shopping centers, tout quick, high-quality treatment for sudden injuries and illnesses. “It’s a growing trend,” says Caroline Rossi Steinberg, vice president for trends analysis at the American Hospital Association. “It’s an efficient way for hospitals to meet growing emergency care needs of the communities.” She says the number of freestanding emergency rooms nationwide has increased in the last five years by about 65 percent.

Locally, Swedish Medical Center developed the region’s first freestanding emergency department in Issaquah in March 2005. It opened a second in Redmond last December, and a third in February in Mill Creek. In March, Evergreen Hospital Medical Center opened its own stand-alone emergency center in a Redmond shopping center.

“We want to radically change the way people think about emergency care,” says Lisa Knutson, operations manager of Swedish Medical Center’s Redmond freestanding ER. The focus: treating people where they live and work, and getting them through the system—and to a doctor—quickly. On average, patients are treated, diagnosed and ready to be discharged within about 90 minutes, as opposed to the state’s average hospital ER wait of four hours. Costs are comparable to those of traditional ERs—at least for the patient.

Two more freestanding emergency centers are being planned by Valley Medical Center and MultiCare for the Covington area, but those projects could be affected by pending legislation sponsored by state Senator Cheryl Pflug, R-Maple Valley, a registered nurse who is calling for more stringent building requirements and a two-year moratorium on new construction of ER centers. Pflug, who is also earning a law degree, says taxpayers are getting soaked by these types of facilities, which she says are being built as “profit centers” under the guise of convenience. “They are driving quality down and driving costs through the ceiling” by focusing on efficiency, she says, adding that the centers also are creating health care monopolies. “It’s all about market domination.” Instead, Pflug advocates expanding and improving primary care systems. But Dr. John Milne, a vice president of medical affairs for Swedish, says that the increasing density in cities such as Redmond and Issaquah is creating increased demand for this type of care: “We are responding to the demographic changes in the population.”

How are these new ERs different from other types of emergency care, and when should you consider using them? Here’s a quick primer on the new emergency centers.

What are they? Neighborhood emergency centers where patients are evaluated, stabilized and treated for acute illnesses or injuries, including those suffering from stroke, severe lacerations, burns, broken bones, allergic reactions and food poisoning. They operate around the clock and are staffed by board-certified ER doctors, nurses and medical technicians.

How do they work? Upon entering, you are directed to a “greeter” desk, where a nurse assesses you, then directs you to an exam room, where an “intake team” (a nurse, an ER technician and physician) takes over. “It’s kind of a NASCAR pit crew phenomenon where everybody is on deck,” Milne says.

How do they differ from “urgent care centers”? Many urgent care centers offer basically the same services a primary care physician would, except on a walk-in basis. Many are not open 24/7. Freestanding emergency departments, however, provide the same diagnostics and initial care as their affiliated hospital’s ER, around the clock. Patients with serious injuries or illnesses—or who require extended treatment or surgery—are transferred by ambulance to the hospital “The only difference is the ‘elevator ride’ from the ER to the hospital bed is a little longer,” says Milne.

Why now? Emergency care in the U.S. is at the breaking point, according to a 2006 report by the Institute of Medicine, an arm of the nonprofit National Academy of Sciences. It noted that about 703 hospitals have closed in the last several years because of cost-cutting measures, while demand for emergency and trauma care has increased dramatically. Use of emergency rooms nationwide has increased 26 percent since 1997, to about 114 million patients, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), possibly due to an increase in the number of uninsured. But only about 13 percent of emergency room visits result in hospital admissions, the report says. “There is a huge gap between what can be done in a traditional outpatient clinic and an acute care hospital,” Milne says. “We’re really just part of the rapid evolution of health care.”

 

Follow Us

82 Million Tons of E-Waste by 2030. Now What?

82 Million Tons of E-Waste by 2030. Now What?

Smart ways to handle old electronics after a holiday upgrade.

Every holiday season, our houses fill with upgraded gadgets and the promise that we’ll deal with the old stuff later. Meanwhile, the drawer of mystery cords multiplies, and some items just get tossed out. Most of us mean well, but those castoff electronics often end up somewhere they really shouldn’t. And with about 59% of…

Going to the Mountains This Winter? Read This.

Going to the Mountains This Winter? Read This.

A new online tool breaks down avalanche basics for anyone planning snowy fun off the beaten path.

I’m a rule follower when it comes to the outdoors. This summer, my family did some backcountry hiking in Whistler and made sure to do everything by the book—texting friends our plan and location, and wearing a bear bell even though it felt a little dorky. It’s reassuring to know you’ve covered the basics before…

Historic Flooding Prompts WA Governor to Declare Emergency

Historic Flooding Prompts WA Governor to Declare Emergency

Rivers are surging around the state amid days of heavy rainfall.

As floodwaters swelled around Washington, threatening low-lying communities along rivers, Gov. Bob Ferguson signed a statewide emergency declaration on Wednesday. Ferguson says he’ll also seek an expedited emergency declaration from the federal government in response to the flooding, which is the result of an atmospheric river that has dumped multiple inches of rain in parts…

Barnes & Noble Is Coming Back to Downtown Seattle

Barnes & Noble Is Coming Back to Downtown Seattle

The bookseller will open a new flagship at 520 Pike, marking the largest retail lease in downtown Seattle since 2020.

Barnes & Noble is returning to downtown Seattle for the first time since early 2020. The national bookseller has signed a 10-year lease for a new flagship at 520 Pike Street, a 29-story tower, taking over 17,538 square feet on the corner of Pike and 6th Avenue. The store is expected to open in the…