Counter Culture: Emerald City Fish & Chips
Gumbo and a spicy tartar sauce might just upend your entire belief system
By Brandon Ferguson August 19, 2025
On the outskirts of Columbia City, Emerald City Fish & Chips is frying like it means it.
I judge every restaurant’s fish and chips by the quality of the cod and the tartar sauce. The Alaskan cod arrives in a Southern-style jacket that crackles at first bite before giving way to moist, flaky glory—glory that’s fried and seasoned.
Now, tartar sauce is where I usually draw the line. I’m a classic, white-and-dill purist. Most “creative” versions taste like disappointment. But Emerald City Fish & Chips, which Stevie Allen opened in 2009 using his grandmother’s Southern recipes with a Northwest twist, sneaks in just the right amount of spicy heat to improve on tradition. I’ve had to reconsider many of my long-held food beliefs after becoming a fan of this spicy tartar sauce.
And yet the headliner here isn’t the fish—it’s the seafood gumbo. It’s house-made, bayou-style, brimming with shrimp, a deep roux, and andouille, ladled over just-barely-al-dente rice that holds its nerve in the bowl. It’s only available Sunday through Tuesday and sells out—so go early. This is the kind of bowl that makes a drive down Rainier Avenue feel like a pilgrimage.
Go for the cod, convert over the tartar sauce, and stay loyal for that gumbo. Emerald City Fish & Chips isn’t just doing fried fish. It’s running a small, well-seasoned rebellion.
About Counter Culture
Brandon Ferguson is a CFO by trade but a foodie at heart. He has a passion for small, humble restaurants that rarely make it onto the radar of mainstream food critics or glossy dining guides. Join him as he discovers warmth, tradition, and authenticity along with great food.
Follow Us
Restaurant Roundup: Holiday Cheer at SLU BRU, StarChefs, and Kabul Closing
Here’s what was served up recently in the Emerald City.
Fusion food has an innate ability to bring us together. In the blending of two (or sometimes more) cultures, new perspectives are unlocked and we are all better for it. Esquire is in agreement, as the magazine has selected Lupe’s Situ Tacos, a Mexican-Lebanese taqueria in Ballard, as one of the 33 best new restaurants…
Counter Culture: Sansonina Ristorante Italiano
An Italian escape hiding in Renton.
Tucked just off Rainier Avenue, across from a Safeway, Sansonina Ristorante Italiano—which opened early in 2019—is the kind of place you drive past for years without noticing until you walk through the door. Once inside, the outside world dissolves, the hum of traffic fades, and suddenly you’re not in Renton anymore. You’re in a dimly…
5 Things to Eat in December
This month’s assignment: Take the pressure off.
There’s something about the end of the year that adds pressure to everything we do. Despite all the talk of holiday cheer and “merry and bright,” heightened expectations can bring a sense of weariness. We’re fretting over feasts and gatherings while working fervently to tie up loose ends—gifts, work, everything—with a pretty bow. Each month,…
Ahead of the Cut
How a tech-minded home cook turned years of tinkering into a chef’s knife powered by 40,000 vibrations per second.
Scott Heimendinger traces his love for knives back to college, when his dad taught him how to cook over the phone. By his junior year he had saved for his first real knife, a JA Henckels Santoku. Compared with the $9 IKEA knife he had been using, “it felt like a laser… things that used…