Skip to content

Sandy Sanctuary

Mercer Island couple find bliss with a cabana on the beach

By Sean Meyers April 25, 2025

In a hilly backyard setting, this small grey shed with white trim features string lights and two white chairs on artificial grass. An outdoor table with a striped umbrella accompanies an American flag, capturing the charm of second homes in regions where Washington is a happy hunting ground for waterfront lots.
PHOTO COURTESY OF THE BLUMENTHALS

This article originally appeared in the March/April 2025 issue of Seattle magazine.

With 8,000 lakes, fifth most in the country, Washington is a happy hunting ground for waterfront lots. Highly popular Lake Chelan, the third-deepest lake in the United States, is not on the top of the list of affordable freshwater options, at least not anywhere near Chelan, where scarce waterfront residential lots start at $2 million. But there’s a hack for that.

Mercer Island residents Sheri and Jeff Blumenthal have been vacationing in the area for 20 years, attracted to the pristine water, family friendly vibe, outdoor culture, dry climate, golf, agricultural productivity, toasty summers, and wine industry. A waterfront lot was beyond their means. Until one day it wasn’t.

“We were just paddling along on the lake and saw a ‘For Sale’ sign on a dock, and we had a Covid-crazy idea,” Jeff recalls.

The road near Chelan (population 4,200) hugs the lake, creating a series of cheaper parcels that aren’t big enough to qualify for a building permit. Over the years, property owners have developed a sort of day-use cabana lifestyle to utilize the waterfront lots. Building permits are not required for uninhabited small accessory structures in Washington, as long as mechanical systems aren’t installed. Portable solar panels and batteries and other energy-efficient outdoor technology are making such tiny off-grid hideaways more feasible.

The Blumenthals bought the cabana lot, and up the hill about a mile away a second larger parcel with a great view, where they constructed a 2,500-square foot modern farmhouse and planted a necklace of wine grapes.

“We built our home in Mercer Island, and enjoyed the process,” Sheri says.

Cabanas provide a roof and three walls for privacy and shade, with a fourth wall that can be opened to the water. Custom models sell for up to $50,000. The Blumenthals budgeted $20,000 plus $1,000 for delivery, and commissioned a lockable unit featuring LP siding, partial bar, refrigerator, and other creature comforts. Family pitched in to build a “pop-up picnic table boat” permanently moored to the dock.

While there was an impulse component to the cabana lot purchase, the Blumenthals are both long-time professionals in finance who had carefully plotted a move to Chelan. First, they had committed to visiting the area frequently for one year. “We weren’t sure that we would want to spend most of our vacations in the same place,” Sheri says. Today, their now college-age kids are frequent visitors. Second, they reduced anxiety by creating a spreadsheet of expected expenses for their second home.

“For the most part, it was pretty accurate,” Jeff notes.

And now, the Blumenthals are very much enjoying their “cabana” lifestyle.

Follow Us

Better Together

Better Together

This Seattle project presents an out-of-the-box model, where investors are also residents, and the design focuses on longevity and tenant retention—not profit.

Growing up in rural Detroit, Chad Dale spent many after-school and weekend hours playing with neighborhood kids in an open lot near his house. It’s an experience he always hoped his children would have someday, but by the time he became a father in Seattle, land was at a premium: either already developed or prohibitively…

A Different Kind of Mattress Store
Sponsored

A Different Kind of Mattress Store

Photos courtesy of Bedrooms and More. If you’re looking for the best mattress shopping experience in Seattle, the right choice often comes down to materials, transparency, and expert guidance – not just price or brand names. Bedrooms & More specializes in natural and organic two-sided mattresses and offers a no-pressure showroom environment where customers can…

Joint Effort

Joint Effort

Rooted in the Northwest craft tradition, Mory Homes offers thoughtful furniture and storage solutions with an architectural point of view.

After more than a decade as the executive director of  local lighting company Graypants, one of the cofounders, Jonathan Junker, decided to return to his architectural roots. In 2019, he was raising a family on Bainbridge Island when he opened his namesake studio. At first, Junker enjoyed the holistic approach to residential design; a few…

Your Land, Your Legacy: A New Way to Build at Suncadia
Sponsored

Your Land, Your Legacy: A New Way to Build at Suncadia

For those who believe that where you live should reflect how you live and how you’ll be remembered Suncadia invites a deeper kind of ownership. It’s an opportunity to create a home that is entirely your own, on some of the most desirable homesites in the Cascades, while benefiting from the ease, support, and long-term…