Skip to content

Rewrite History or Get Sued: Difficulties Faced in the Making of ‘Selma’

Dr. King's famous speeches in the movie aren't recited as we know them. Here's why

By Stephanie Reid January 19, 2015

selmapostweb

This article originally appeared on Avvo.com.

On December 25, American moviegoers were offered a glimpse into history as the critically acclaimed film Selma hit theaters. The movie offers a portrayal of the leadership, obstacles and milestones faced by relentless peacemaker Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. as he and his supporters marched from Selma to Montgomery, Alabama, in the name of civil rights and equality.

However, anyone with even a novice knowledge of Dr. King’s famous speeches will immediately notice a glaring oddity in the movie: the words and content so famously attributed to this fearless leader are completely altered, paraphrased or rewritten altogether.

How can this be? The answer is simple: copyright. Much like a famous song, novel or even a catchphrase, Dr. King’s famous civil rights speeches have been legally protected such that no other entity can reproduce the words for commercial gain, or even for non-profit purposes, without the express written consent of his family. And, good luck with that.

Currently, the King family has issued a license solely to Steven Spielberg for the right to reproduce the content of Dr. King’s works for a film and commercial gain. The makers of Selma — from Paramount Pictures — were unsuccessful in negotiating a similar deal.

Historical copyrights of Dr. King’s speeches

Copyrighting a historical speech is often thought of as a safe way to secure the legacy of a prominent figure, eliminating the possibility that the entertainment industry will posthumously capitalize on the efforts of the famous figure.

There are limits — speeches written or rendered prior to 1923 are considered within the public domain and are not subject to U.S. copyright laws. Likewise, speeches made by any member of Congress or the U.S. President (while in office) cannot by copyrighted and shall remain forever in the public domain.

However, famous speeches and quotes made after 1923 are subject to the rigorous copyright laws currently in place – despite fervent efforts by moviemakers, documentarians and authors to urge Congress to rewrite these restrictive laws.

The estate of Dr. King, which is managed by the for-profit company King, Inc., has collected millions of dollars on his memory and works. Not only has the family sued and received payments from several authors and television channels, it even managed to siphon $2.7 million in licensing fees from a group that raised money to erect a statue of Dr. King in Washington, D.C. The group even had to change its name from the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Foundation because King, Inc. wanted an additional $20,000 to use the name.

The actions of the King heirs via King, Inc. have lead many to ponder whether these copyright laws are actually doing more harm than good. “I think Martin Luther King must be spinning in his grave,” former King lieutenant Bill Rutherford told CBS in 2002. “He attempted his entire life to communicate ideas for free. To communicate, not to sell.”

Status of speech copyright laws

Congress has started to strongly consider amending its copyright laws, despite several retroactive applications of 95-, 76- and 56-year protection terms. In early 2014, Congress took testimony from several industry experts on the pros and cons of re-drafting current copyright laws to reflect the needs of Americans in the digital age.

In the words of intellectual property law professor Peter Jaszi, whose testimony was particularly relevant to the issues surrounding the legacy of Dr. King, “citizens’ ability to make socially and economically positive uses of copyrighted materials without permission is a positive right, connected to the First Amendment right to freedom of expression.”

For now, the civil rights legacy of Dr. King will live on in the snippets of content allowed by the family, until the entire library of his speeches and letters becomes part of the public domain — which is not likely to occur until at least 2039.

Photo via Flikr: “Alabama civil rights movement: Selma to Montgomery march.” Courtesy of the Jack Rabin collection on Alabama civil rights and southern activists, 1941-2004 (bulk 1956-1974), Historical Collections and Labor Archives, Eberly Family Special Collections Library, University Libraries, Pennsylvania State University.

Avvo makes legal easier by providing free answers from lawyers, client reviews, and detailed profiles for 97% of all licensed attorneys in the U.S., so you can find the lawyer who’s right for you. Avvo Advocates write about legal issues in everyday life on the Avvo NakedLaw blog.

 

Follow Us

Three Things to See at Seattle Art Fair This Weekend

Three Things to See at Seattle Art Fair This Weekend

From tufted wool creatures to shimmering mother-of-pearl waves, these standout works demand a closer look.

There was joy in the air as the Seattle Art Fair opened the doors for its 10th edition Thursday, July 23, with visitors streaming in to the cool, dark interior of Lumen Field Event Center to be greeted with flutes of champagne and a fantastic feast of art.  Though the theme this year is textile…

Rearview Mirror: Storytellers in Clay, Wild Seattle, and an Alaskan Feast I'll Never Forget

Rearview Mirror: Storytellers in Clay, Wild Seattle, and an Alaskan Feast I’ll Never Forget

Things I did, saw, ate, learned, or read in the past week (or so).

CLAY RELATIONS I went to see the Seattle Asian Art Museum’s new Kondō family exhibit expecting beautiful ceramics, and there are plenty. What I didn’t expect was a fascinating story that starts with samurai. Long before pottery became the family trade, earlier generations guarded Kiyomizudera, a historic Buddhist temple in Kyoto. That role vanished when…

Studio Sessions: Jade Solomon Curtis  

Studio Sessions: Jade Solomon Curtis  

With an interest in how bodies retain memory, emotion, and experience, the award-winning choreographer and interdisciplinary artist Jade Solomon Curtis presents an immersive work at Seattle’s historic Union station. 

Discover choreographer Jade Solomon Curtis and her immersive dance installation, Keeper of Sadness, at Seattle’s historic Union Station this August.

Northwest Tune-Up Bike and Music Festival Brings Big Air and Loud Sets to Bellingham

Northwest Tune-Up Bike and Music Festival Brings Big Air and Loud Sets to Bellingham

The three-day festival celebrates its fifth year with bike competitions and a genre-spanning music lineup—plus one unforgettable band of mummies.

If I were to summarize the sensation of attending Northwest Tune-Up, Bellingham’s three-day bike and music festival, in one image, it would be watching Tomomi Nishikubo—a Japanese street trials biker—doing acrobatic acts of derring-do on his bike while Seattle rockers Thunderpussy shred in the distance. My second lasting impression of the festival would be rounding…